MAL: this username.
Sora wo Kakeru Shoujo
Hidamari Sketch x365
Read or Die
Great Teacher Onizuka
Kanon 2006 (English DVD)
sola (see nauXolo's perfect review)
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni/Kai (overrated)
Super Dimensional Fortress Macross
Extreme Goodbye Mr. Despair
Code Geass R2
I rate from an average of a ~6 and go from there. And because I don't watch crappy anime often, the scores will be above average. ^^
10.0 to 9.0 - Must-see/near-perfect.
9.0 to 8.0 - Recommended/awesome.
8.0 to 7.0 - One-time watch/okay-ish.
7.0 to 6.0 - Optional/good enough.
6.0 to 5.0 - Not recommended/average.
5.0 to 1.0 - Stay far, far away/in the crapper.
Animation - Includes quality, character designs, appealness, CG, fluidity, lighting effects, directing, etc..
Sound - OP, ED, voice acting, background music.
Story - Make sense, depth, execution, flow, etc.. If the anime has no plot, I'm looking for mostly execution of the individual episodes.
Characters - Appealness, development, likeables/hateables, charms, originality, chemistry, etc..
Value - Is it worth watching/keeping/buying? Classic? Must-watch? Disgrace?
Enjoyment - S/E.